Friday, February 9, 2007

Kate Chopin

I thought the three stories by Kate Chopin were very exciting. She wrote about, love, romance, scandal, race, and social class, and her stories were so unpredictable that I didn't know what to expect next. My favorite story by Chopin is called, "Desiree's Baby," because I was so surprised by the ending.
When I first started reading, "Desiree's Baby," I couldn't understand why Desiree was abandoned . The writing said, "The prevailing belief was that she had been purposely left by a party of Texans, whose canvas-covered wagon, late in the day, had crossed the ferry that Coton Mais kept, just below the plantation." I couldn't tell if Chopin was trying to give us the idea that she was left by people who didn't want her, or if possibly, maybe slaves had left her their because she looked white, so they thought she could have a chance at a better way of living if a white family found her and adopted her.
Once Desiree was found by a loving family, it seemed like a fairytale. She was beautiful, in love, wealthy, happy, and pregnant by her husband who was everything to her. But shortly after the baby was born the fairytale started to crumble. I liked when Desirees mother looks at the baby and said in surprise, "This is not the baby," and Desiree just laughed at her reaction and began talking about how much the baby has grown. She didn't even realize that anything was different, she had just thought that her mother was surprised at how much the baby had grown. I think that shows how much Desiree had cared about and loved her child.
When I read the end of the story I was so surprised. I never would have thought that Desiree would take her baby and walk into a body of water, never to be seen again. I believe she did that because her husband meant everything to her, and without his love for her and their child she felt that she had nothing worth living for. She was in shock, and I don't think she fully new what she was doing at that moment because if she was aware, I don't think she would have ended her babys life. She could have reaised her baby at her mothers house, and provided a great life for it just like she had. I was also shocked when I read the last line of the book, "night and day, I thank the good God for having so arranged our lives that our dear Armand will never know that his mother, who adores him, belongs to the race that is cursed with the brand of slavery." That means that Armand was just like Desiree, his mother was black and his father white, but because they were both light skinned they never knew it. Thats why the baby was born so dark. Armand had drove Desiree to her death by making her feel so ashamed of where she had come from, and all along he came from the same place. I wonder if he'll hate himself for what he is, just like he hated his own wife and child for being of mixed race. I still can't understand why he acted that way towards her when he found out that she was of mixed race. If he loved Desiree and his child so much, why wouldn't he let love overcome his feelings of hatred for a different race.
At the end of class on Friday, I heard someone mention that they didn't believe Desiree had one black parent and one white parent, they thought that Armand was the one that caused thier child to be darked skin. I agree with that. In the writting Desiree said, "Look at my hair, it is brown; and my eyes are gray," And my skin tone is fair," "Look at my hand; whiter than yours." I believe that Desiree was the pure one, and it's sad that she had ended her life, along with her child's life, just because of how Armand had made her feel, which was ashamed of herself. I know that Desiree wouldn't even care that her husband was of mixed race, but she was never able to find out the truth.

5 comments:

elphingirl said...

I have to agree with you about the whole things that concern Desiree. I believe that she was acutally white and pure unlike her own husband. This story really shows the shame and ignorance that these people had. I find that it is alittle stupid to think this way but I understand that they didn't know better.

ShanM125 said...

Kate Chopin leaves us hanging at the end of "Desiree's Baby." What happened to Armand? Did he make a mistake in sending Desiree away with the baby? Or did he just pretend he never saw the letter? I think this is what makes Chopin's writing so unique. There could be so many different endings.

I agree that Desiree felt she had nothing to live for without her husband. Although she loved her baby so much, she couldn't stand the thought of living without Armand. But why hadn't she left the baby with her mother and took her own life? Maybe she thought no one would love her baby as much as she would, and no one would take good care of her baby.

I enjoyed reading Kate Chopin because it leaves your mind pondering everything that happened in the story.

andrea said...

I think that its interesting that you bring up the point about her being left by slaves. maybe both Armand and Calixta were decendents of the race cursed with slavery. neither of them may have been as pure as once thought. and if that were the case then i think they were more perfect for each other than they realized. I just find it disapointing that with this one question of her character she decides a fate of suicide for her and her baby. thats not right, expecially since she murdered her baby, i dont understand how her motherly love could fade so quickly.

Ginger said...

Chopin was trying to create a question in your mind, so that when you find out the baby is not white the first you assume is that it’s Desiree’s fault. I truly think that if her family were moving, which was the hint they probably couldn’t provide for her and felt that whom even was in the plantation would in some way provide a better life for her even if she became a servant in the house.

The logical reason Desiree didn’t notice the change in her son is that she spend every day with him you don’t notice slight changes when you look at a person everyday. For example my boyfriend is losing weight and it took me about three months to truly notice the change in his weight.

I have the same take on Desiree you (I was the one your were talking with) I don’t think she was mulatto I think she was white and Armand was the raise that the baby was darker. Don’t get me wrong everyone has an opinion, but if both were mulatto the baby would have been much dark I think then described. I thought that it was sad too that Desiree would never know the true story and she was not to blame.

Taysha said...

Yes the ending was very surprising. I liked how you mentioned the fact that desirees mother looked at the baby. You would think that her being the grandmother she would have more love for her granddaughter, but because the baby ia a little darker she looks at it in discuss.I found that part rather shocking.